In a significant legal development, Judge Reed O’Connor has allowed the lawsuit filed by social media platform X (formerly known as Twitter) against Media Matters for America (MMFA) to proceed. The lawsuit, initiated in Texas last year, accuses MMFA of causing reputational and financial harm to X through a report that allegedly led to several advertisers severing ties with the platform.

What makes this case particularly intriguing is its setting. Despite neither X nor MMFA being headquartered in Texas, the judge ruled that the lawsuit could be heard in the state. The reasoning? MMFA’s report implicated Texas-based companies, including Oracle and AT&T, which was sufficient for Judge O’Connor to establish jurisdiction. X, currently based in California, is reportedly planning to relocate its headquarters to Texas—a move being considered by its owner, Elon Musk, who is no stranger to controversy.
Interestingly, this is not your typical defamation case. X doesn’t dispute the truthfulness of MMFA’s claims. In fact, the company acknowledges that some of its ads did appear alongside objectionable content, including racist materials. However, X argues that these instances were rare and that MMFA manipulated the platform’s algorithm to exacerbate the problem. According to the lawsuit, MMFA allegedly created accounts that followed both racists and major brands, repeatedly refreshing their feeds until ads appeared next to offensive content. X claims this was done intentionally to mislead advertisers and damage the platform’s reputation.
Adding another layer of complexity, Judge O’Connor himself has a personal financial interest in Tesla, another company owned by Musk. National Public Radio (NPR) reported that O’Connor holds shares in Tesla valued between $15,001 and $50,000. This conflict of interest led him to recuse himself from a separate case involving advertisers who dropped X. However, he remains involved in the current lawsuit against MMFA, ensuring that the legal battle between X and the media watchdog is far from over.
Source: